Tax considerations of making a charitable donation via a will
Question
My client is wanting to make a charitable donation via their will.
To make the donation, the estate will sell an asset with a market value of $200,000 that currently has an unrealised capital gain of $50,000, after factoring in the 50 per cent discount. The sale proceeds will be donated to the charity.
Will the client’s estate receive a tax deduction for the donation to offset the capital gain and other income?
Answer
No, donations made by an estate are not entitled to a tax deduction. Assuming a marginal tax rate of 30%, the estate will have a tax liability of $15,000 (noting that estates aren’t liable for the Medicare levy).
An alternative scenario worth considering is for the estate to donate the asset to the charity instead of selling the asset and donating the proceeds.
In this alternative scenario, the realised capital gain would be disregarded. As a result, there would be a $15,000 tax saving and therefore $15,000 more to pass to beneficiaries of the estate (whether this be the charity or other beneficiaries).
Under this scenario, it’s advisable to contact the specific charity to confirm their ability to receive a donation by way asset transfer.
A further option worth considering is making the donation while the client is alive. This could be more tax effective, depending on the client’s circumstances. For instance, if they were to sell the asset and donate the full proceeds of $200,000, they would receive a tax deduction for the full $200,000.
This tax deduction could then offset the net realised gain of $50,000 and provide a further tax deduction of $150,000 that could be used to offset other assessable in the current year or carried forward for use in future years (noting that carried forward capital losses are lost once the individual passes away).
Assuming the client can use this tax deduction over a few years at a marginal tax rate of 32% (including Medicare levy), they will not pay tax on the realised capital gain and will save tax of $48,000 on other income. Overall this option provides a tax saving of $63,000 when compared to the original strategy of selling the asset in the estate and donating the proceeds.
Making donations while alive can provide a sense of joy or satisfaction though also depends on the client having sufficient assets/income to live off after making the donation. A combination of the different options could also be considered.